Oklahoma fans spent the season fixated on Mateer and an offense they called broken, with anger spreading from Arbuckle to Venables as the losses piled up. A shocking win over Texas offered brief relief, but the South Carolina blowout left them in mutinous despair at 4-4.
From Reddit fan threads · through Wk 9 · Oct 26–Nov 1 · 4-4
Season misery
75Miserable
Worst week
97Wk 3 · Sep 14–20
Best week
31Wk 1 · Aug 31–Sep 6
Weekly misery, Monday to Sunday. Above the line is miserable; below is happy.
Storylines
what fans talked about, week by week
Season-long
Fans hammered Mateer every week for staring down receivers and missing open targets, briefly praised his Mississippi State game, then declared the Heisman hype never warranted after South Carolina.
“John Mateer might be the worst college QB I’ve ever seen and I’ve seen Jackson Arnold play”