Week 3 · 2025–26 season
Dolphins
L 21-31 at Bills · Sep 18, 2025
Misery Index · Despair
Dolphins fans are done defending T.Tagovailoa and openly rooting for a blowout bad enough to force real changes.
The emotional rollercoaster
Fan misery across the game window. Up is worse.
What happened
Down four with the ball in the fourth, T.Tagovailoa threw it directly to T.Bernard at the BUF 17, and the game effectively ended there. The T.Hill touchdown that briefly made it interesting feels like a footnote now, drowned out by K.Shakir running free twice and J.Allen scrambling untouched for 19. Three weeks in, the fanbase isn't arguing about the quarterback anymore so much as wondering what a blowout might actually change.
What fans said
“I'm 100% done with Tua at this point. We will never win a playoff game with him.”
u/CtrlAltDelamain▲ 207despair
“This was the worst possible outcome. If we get blown out there's a possibility of actual changes.”
u/radio_jake▲ 143despair
“This team has beaten me down so much for so long, I just do not care the same way anymore.”
u/PSUDolphins▲ 88despair
“I genuinely fucking hate this team and everything it stands for.”
u/shlimey_▲ 23rage
“Thank you Zach Sieler. He’s made 0 fucking plays this season for the Dolphins, but comes up big for Buffalo.”
u/dirtyricher▲ 25betrayal
“Tua cannot see the field anymore. He doesn’t see his receivers.”
u/OblivionNA▲ 107frustration
14 more
“This game ain’t on MMD , he called a real good game and was locked in. Bro can’t overcome sorry ass Tua and Sielers fuck up.”
u/No_Delay_1476▲ 93frustration
“This game is what 8-8 feels like every year”
u/DiggingPodcast▲ 63frustration
“I’ve been a Tua defender since he’s been drafted and you’re right. He’s just not the guy and it’s impossible to keep defending him.”
u/justicebetter▲ 45betrayal
“Kincaid hitting someone after the play is fine but brooks taking an upright Allen to the ground is a crime”
u/JoeRo628▲ 27rage
“Dude I think I'd rather go 2-15 with both Ws against the bills than go 9-8 with no W against the bills.”
u/OLD_WET_HOLE▲ 26rage
“but seriously- fuck this team. WE COUD HAVE BEEN DOING THIS THE WHOLE TIME”
u/Affectionate_Elk_272▲ 16rage
“Tua scrambling, extending the play and making a 1st down pass and then scrambling for a 1st down and then scoring a TD on the drive. What even is this”
u/Trojanmandan▲ 18joy
“Kincaid levels a guy after the whistle and nothing and we tackle the guy with the ball and get a penalty”
u/DIFTS24▲ 15rage
“Dude can take his cowboy hat he walks in with and shove it up his ass”
u/capslock0505▲ 14rage
“the entire Miami Dolphins defense is antifa”
u/TaxFar6890▲ 13rage
“**Leave Anthony Weaver in Buffalo.**”
u/Number333▲ 13rage
“Grier built a steaming pile of dog shit of a roster.”
u/TexAg27▲ 13rage
“THATS A BIG BOY DRIVE RIGHT THERE LETS GO”
u/CasanovaBaby___▲ 13joy
“Goes to show how bad this roster is if Zach Seiler is our best player. Outright pathetic roster construction by Mr. Grier.”
u/Gunnar2019▲ 13rage